A fair test: what I change, what I measure and what I keep the same
Machine translation
Learn
An experiment is a test for answering a question. Gus wonders: do beans grow more with more light? To find out, he does a fair test.
In a fair test you change only one thing. You measure something else. And you keep everything else the same. Gus changes the light: one plant pot next to the window and another in a cupboard. He measures how much each plant grows. He keeps the soil, the water and the pot the same.
what I change the light what I measure how much it grows what I keep the same soil and water What I change, what I measure and what I keep the same If you change two things, you do not know which one caused the effect. Gus puts one plant by the window with lots of water and another in the cupboard with little water. If they grow differently, was it the light or the water? He does not know. That test is not fair.
Here two things change: it is not fair Living things are not all the same. A seed may not sprout and a plant may be ill. That is why you use several seeds or several plants in each group: for example, five seeds in each cup.
Five seeds in each group Look after living things. Do not leave them without water or light until they become unwell. When you finish, water the plants and put them back in the light.
Worked examples
Example 1
Julie wants to know whether bean plants grow more with more light. She plans the test. What does she change, what does she measure and what does she keep the same?
- She changes only one thing: the light. One pot next to the window and another in a cupboard, for a few days.
- She measures something else: how much each plant grows, with a ruler.
- She keeps the soil, the water, the pot and the kind of bean the same.
She changes the light, measures how much they grow and keeps the soil, the water and the pot the same.
Watch out! Many children also change the water without noticing.
Example 2
Gus puts a pot with a bean by the window. He puts another, with more water, in the cupboard. Is it a fair test?
- Count what changes: the light and the water.
- That is two things at once.
- If the plants grow differently, he does not know whether it was the light or the water.
It is not fair. He must change only one thing: the light or the water.
Watch out! Many children think that changing more things teaches more.
Example 3
Tony wants to know whether lentil seeds sprout sooner than sunflower seeds. He puts one seed of each kind in a cup. What is missing?
- A single seed may not sprout even if it is a good one.
- It is better to put five seeds of each kind.
- The cups, the cotton wool and the water will be the same.
He must use several seeds of each kind and keep everything else the same.
Watch out! Many children rely on a single seed.
A challenge to think about
With an adult, plant four seeds in each of two cups with the same soil. Put one cup next to a window and the other in a place with less light. Water both the same and measure the plants with a ruler. If a seed does not sprout, that is data too.
Practise
Rounds of 10 questions. Choose a level:
Your grade in this topic:No grade yetDo a round at the Basic level to get a grade.
Next topic: Recording results in tables and drawing bar charts and line graphs →