Sign in

← All revision topics

English variety

Choosing the most suitable chart; misleading graphs in the media

Machine translation

Around age 12 · Usually taught in ⁨Key Stage 3⁩ · Free

Learn

  1. Each chart is good for something. Choosing well depends on what we want to show.

    A bar chart compares categories: fruit, sports, groups. A line graph shows how something changes over time. A pie chart shows the parts of a whole, which add up to 100%.

    A graph can also mislead even when the data are true. The trick is in how it is drawn. The most common one is an axis that does not start at 0.

    9092949698100AB
    Sales are 92 and 98, but the axis starts at 90: bar B looks four times bar A
  2. With the axis starting at 0, the two bars are almost the same height. That is why you should always look at where the axis starts.

    020406080100AB
    The same data with the axis starting at 0: 98 is only a little more than 92
  3. There are more tricks. Two graphs with different scales look the same, but they are worth different amounts.

    2468Gus10203040Julie
    Both bars reach the third mark: one is worth 6 and the other, 30
  4. A picture that is twice as tall and twice as wide looks four times bigger, even if the data are only double. In a 3D sector, the part at the front looks bigger. And if the points in time are equally spaced when different numbers of years pass, the line distorts the trend.

    20192020
    The 2020 picture is twice as tall and twice as wide: it looks four times bigger
  5. Before you believe a graph, ask: what does it measure? Where does the axis start? Is the scale fair? Who made it, and why?

Worked examples

Example 1

Tony wants to show how the height of his plant changes each week for two months. Which chart suits him best?

  1. Ask yourself what he wants to show: a change over time.
  2. The chart that shows change over time is a line graph.
  3. The weeks go along the bottom axis, in order, and the height goes on the left-hand axis.

A line graph.

Watch out! Many people choose bars here. They would work, but a line shows the trend better: you can see whether it goes up, goes down or stays the same.

Common mistake

Example 2

A poster by Ellie shows the sales of two bakeries with bars, and the axis starts at 90. Hers sells 98 and the one next door sells 92. How many times bigger does her bar look, and how much more does she really sell?

9092949698100Next doorEllie
  1. The bar for 98 rises 8 above the axis (98 − 90) and the bar for 92 rises 2 (92 − 90).
  2. It looks 8 ÷ 2 = 4 times bigger.
  3. In fact she sells 98 − 92 = 6 more, and 98 is only a little more than 92.

It looks four times bigger, but she only sells 6 more.

Watch out! Many people here believe what they see and say she sells four times as much.

Common mistake

Example 3

A newspaper draws the sales of Mara's shop with a picture. From 2019 to 2020 sales double and the picture doubles in height and width. How many times bigger does the picture look?

20192020
  1. If the height doubles, the picture is 2 times taller.
  2. If the width doubles, it is 2 times wider.
  3. The area is height × width: 2 × 2 = 4 times bigger.

It looks four times bigger, but sales have only doubled.

Watch out! Many people here say it looks double, and the eye sees four times.

Common mistake

A challenge to think about

Find a graph in a newspaper, in a book or on the internet. Look at what it measures, where the axis starts and whether the type of chart fits the data. Write a sentence saying what the graph really tells you.

Practise

Rounds of 10 questions. Choose a level:

Your grade in this topic:No grade yetDo a round at the Basic level to get a grade.