Sign in

← All revision topics

English variety

Same perimeter, different area (and the other way round)

Machine translation

Around age 10 · Usually taught in ⁨Year 6⁩ · Free

Learn

  1. Perimeter and area are different measurements. Two rectangles can have the same perimeter and different areas.

    Imagine a piece of string 16 cm long. With it you can make a rectangle of 1 by 7, 2 by 6, 3 by 5 or 4 by 4. They all have a perimeter of 16 cm.

    ABCD
    Four rectangles with the same string: A, B, C and D
  2. But their areas are 7, 12, 15 and 16 cm². With the same string, the closer a rectangle is to a square, the more area it encloses.

    LengthWidthPerimeterArea
    1716 cm7 cm²
    2616 cm12 cm²
    3516 cm15 cm²
    4416 cm16 cm²
    Same perimeter, different area
  3. It also works the other way round. With 12 squares of 1 cm² you can make a rectangle of 1 by 12, 2 by 6 or 3 by 4. They all have an area of 12 cm², but their perimeters are 26, 16 and 14 cm.

    LengthWidthAreaPerimeter
    11212 cm²26 cm
    2612 cm²16 cm
    3412 cm²14 cm
    Same area, different perimeter
  4. So it is not true that a bigger perimeter gives a bigger area, or that the same perimeter gives the same area. To compare areas, work out the areas. To compare perimeters, work out the perimeters.

    If you double one side of a rectangle, the area doubles: 3 × 2 = 6 cm² and 6 × 2 = 12 cm². If you double both sides, the area becomes 4 times greater: 6 × 4 = 24 cm².

    3 cm2 cm6 cm4 cm
    3 by 2 has 6 cm². With both sides doubled, 6 by 4 has 24 cm²

Worked examples

Example 1

Julie has 20 cm of string and wants to make a rectangle. Which encloses more: the 2 by 8 one, the 4 by 6 one or the 5 by 5 one?

  1. All three have the same perimeter: 20 cm.
  2. Work out the areas: 2 × 8 = 16, 4 × 6 = 24 and 5 × 5 = 25.
  3. The greatest is 25 cm².

The 5 by 5 one, the square, encloses more.

Watch out! Here many people think that the longest one encloses more, or that all three enclose the same because they use the same string.

Common mistake

Example 2

Ellie makes two chocolate bars of 12 cm²: one of 2 by 6 and another of 3 by 4. Which needs less ribbon around it?

  1. Both have the same area, 12 cm². You have to compare the perimeters.
  2. 2 × (2 + 6) = 16 cm y 2 × (3 + 4) = 14 cm.
  3. The smaller perimeter is 14 cm.

The 3 by 4 one needs less ribbon.

Watch out! Here many people think that, since both have the same area, they need the same ribbon.

Common mistake

Example 3

A rectangle measures 3 cm by 2 cm. Both its sides are doubled. How many times greater does its area become?

  1. Before: 3 × 2 = 6 cm².
  2. Now it measures 6 cm by 4 cm: 6 × 4 = 24 cm².
  3. 24 ÷ 6 = 4.

The area becomes 4 times greater.

Watch out! Here many people say 2 times, because the sides have been doubled.

Common mistake

A challenge to think about

Cut a piece of string 24 cm long. On a sheet of squared paper, use it to make as many rectangles with whole-number sides as you can. Work out the area of each one. Which has the most area? And which the least? What shape is the one that encloses the most area?

Practise

Rounds of 10 questions. Choose a level:

Your grade in this topic:No grade yetDo a round at the Basic level to get a grade.

Next topic: Area of a triangle →