Comparing fractions: same denominator or same numerator
Machine translation
Learn
Julie and Gus have two pizzas of the same size. Each pizza has 8 equal slices. Julie eats 3 slices: . Gus eats 5 slices: . Who eats more?
and : the parts are the same size Both fractions have the same denominator, 8. The parts are the same size. So the one with more parts is greater. Compare the numerators: 5 is greater than 3. Gus eats more.
We use the signs < and >. The open side faces the greater fraction. We write < and also > . If two fractions are equal, we use =.
Now look at and . The two fractions have the same numerator. A whole is cut into 4 equal parts or into 8 equal parts. With more parts, each part is smaller. So < .
and : with more parts, each part is smaller With the same numerator, look at the denominator. The smaller denominator wins, because its parts are bigger. Compare and : both have 3 parts, but the parts in are bigger. So > .
One whole can be written as . If the numerator is less than the denominator, the fraction is less than 1. For example, < 1. If the numerator and denominator are equal, the fraction is equal to 1.
< = 1 Be careful! You can only compare if the whole is the same. of a small pizza can be less than of a very big pizza.
Worked examples
Example 1
Julie paints of a wall in Mara's shop. Gus paints of another wall of the same size. Who paints more? Write the comparison with a sign.
- Look at the denominators: both are 8. The parts are the same size.
- Compare the numerators: 3 and 5. Since 5 is greater than 3, more parts are painted on Gus's wall.
- Write the sign with the open side facing the greater fraction: < .
Gus paints more: < .
Watch out! Many people write > here, because they mix up < and >. Remember: the open side faces the greater fraction.
Example 2
Tony and Julie have two ribbons of the same length. Tony cuts his ribbon into 3 equal pieces and keeps 1 piece. Julie cuts hers into 5 equal pieces and keeps 1 piece. Who has the longer piece?
- Write the fractions: Tony has and Julie has .
- Both numerators are 1. Look at the denominators: 3 and 5.
- A ribbon cut into 3 pieces has longer pieces than a ribbon cut into 5 pieces.
- So > .
Tony has the longer piece: > .
Watch out! Many people say that is greater here, because 5 is greater than 3. But with 5 pieces, each piece is shorter.
Example 3
Crumb eats of a cake. Gus eats of another cake of the same size. Who eats more cake?
- Both have the same denominator, 5. Compare the numerators: 4 and 5.
- is 1 whole: Gus eats the whole cake.
- 4 is less than 5, so is less than 1.
Gus eats more: < .
Watch out! Many people say that is greater than 1 here, because 4 is greater than 1. Compare the numerator with the denominator, not with 1.
A challenge to think about
Choose a denominator, for example 10. Write 3 fractions with that denominator, all less than 1, and order them from smallest to largest. Then choose a numerator, for example 3. Write 3 fractions with that numerator and denominators greater than 3, and order them. What is different?
Practise
Rounds of 10 questions. Choose a level:
Your grade in this topic:No grade yetDo a round at the Basic level to get a grade.