Sign in

← All revision topics

English variety

Comparing fractions: same denominator or same numerator

Machine translation

Around age 9 · Usually taught in ⁨Year 3⁩ · Free

Learn

  1. Julie and Gus have two pizzas of the same size. Each pizza has 8 equal slices. Julie eats 3 slices: . Gus eats 5 slices: . Who eats more?

    and : the parts are the same size
  2. Both fractions have the same denominator, 8. The parts are the same size. So the one with more parts is greater. Compare the numerators: 5 is greater than 3. Gus eats more.

    We use the signs < and >. The open side faces the greater fraction. We write < and also > . If two fractions are equal, we use =.

    Now look at and . The two fractions have the same numerator. A whole is cut into 4 equal parts or into 8 equal parts. With more parts, each part is smaller. So < .

    and : with more parts, each part is smaller
  3. With the same numerator, look at the denominator. The smaller denominator wins, because its parts are bigger. Compare and : both have 3 parts, but the parts in are bigger. So > .

    One whole can be written as . If the numerator is less than the denominator, the fraction is less than 1. For example, < 1. If the numerator and denominator are equal, the fraction is equal to 1.

    < = 1
  4. Be careful! You can only compare if the whole is the same. of a small pizza can be less than of a very big pizza.

Worked examples

Example 1

Julie paints of a wall in Mara's shop. Gus paints of another wall of the same size. Who paints more? Write the comparison with a sign.

  1. Look at the denominators: both are 8. The parts are the same size.
  2. Compare the numerators: 3 and 5. Since 5 is greater than 3, more parts are painted on Gus's wall.
  3. Write the sign with the open side facing the greater fraction: < .

Gus paints more: < .

Watch out! Many people write > here, because they mix up < and >. Remember: the open side faces the greater fraction.

Common mistake

Example 2

Tony and Julie have two ribbons of the same length. Tony cuts his ribbon into 3 equal pieces and keeps 1 piece. Julie cuts hers into 5 equal pieces and keeps 1 piece. Who has the longer piece?

  1. Write the fractions: Tony has and Julie has .
  2. Both numerators are 1. Look at the denominators: 3 and 5.
  3. A ribbon cut into 3 pieces has longer pieces than a ribbon cut into 5 pieces.
  4. So > .

Tony has the longer piece: > .

Watch out! Many people say that is greater here, because 5 is greater than 3. But with 5 pieces, each piece is shorter.

Common mistake

Example 3

Crumb eats of a cake. Gus eats of another cake of the same size. Who eats more cake?

  1. Both have the same denominator, 5. Compare the numerators: 4 and 5.
  2. is 1 whole: Gus eats the whole cake.
  3. 4 is less than 5, so is less than 1.

Gus eats more: < .

Watch out! Many people say that is greater than 1 here, because 4 is greater than 1. Compare the numerator with the denominator, not with 1.

Common mistake

A challenge to think about

Choose a denominator, for example 10. Write 3 fractions with that denominator, all less than 1, and order them from smallest to largest. Then choose a numerator, for example 3. Write 3 fractions with that numerator and denominators greater than 3, and order them. What is different?

Practise

Rounds of 10 questions. Choose a level:

Your grade in this topic:No grade yetDo a round at the Basic level to get a grade.

Next topic: Equivalent fractions and simplifying →