Evaluating and comparing strategies; choosing the most efficient
Machine translation
Learn
The same problem can be solved in several ways. All of them may reach the right answer, but not all are equally efficient. A strategy is efficient if it reaches the answer in few steps, with little risk of error, and also with large numbers.
Look at this problem. Gus and Julie have 100 stickers between them. Gus has 18 more than Julie. How many stickers does each of them have? You can try: 45 and 63 make 108; 40 and 58 make 98. You need several attempts and you have to hit on the right one.
Julie Gus Total 1 45 63 108 2 40 58 98 3 41 59 100 Trying: three attempts before it makes 100 The rods are quicker. Take away the extra 18: that leaves 82. Share it between the two: 41 each. Gus has 41 + 18 = 59. That is two calculations, and there is nothing to guess.
With rods: 100 − 18 = 82 and 82 ÷ 2 = 41 When the numbers grow, some strategies stop working. Drawing 1000 pencils is impossible, and a table with 42 rows is very long. A division solves it in a single step: 1000 ÷ 24.
Strategy With 1000 pencils Drawing 1000 drawings Table 42 rows Dividing 1 calculation How many steps each strategy needs To choose, ask yourself three questions. Then check with another strategy, even if it is slower.
Does it reach the right answer? Is it quick and safe? Does it work with large numbers?
Three questions for choosing a strategy
Worked examples
Example 1
Julie solves the sticker problem in two ways: by trying and with rods. Both give her 41 and 59. Compare the two strategies.
- Trying: 45 and 63 make 108; 40 and 58 make 98; 41 and 59 make 100. That is 3 attempts.
- With rods: 100 − 18 = 82 and 82 ÷ 2 = 41. Then 41 + 18 = 59. That is 2 calculations.
- Compare: trying needs several attempts and depends on guessing right; rods do not.
- Use the other one to check: 41 + 59 = 100 and 59 − 41 = 18.
Julie has 41 and Gus has 59. Rods are more efficient, and trying is useful for checking.
Watch out! Here many people say the two are the same because they give the same answer.
Example 2
Mara pays £4.80 for 6 pens. How much do 15 pens cost? Solve it with a table and with the unitary method, and compare.
| Pens | 6 | 12 | 3 | 15 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Euros | 4.80 | 9.60 | 2.40 | ? |
- Table: 6 pens cost £4.80; 12, double, £9.60; 3, half, £2.40. Since 15 = 12 + 3, they cost £9.60 + £2.40 = £12.
- Unitary method: £4.80 ÷ 6 = £0.80 each, and £0.80 × 15 = £12.
- Both give £12.
- Compare: the table is handy if 15 is made from doubles and halves; the unitary method works with any number.
15 pens cost £12.
Watch out! Here many people multiply £4.80 × 15 without dividing by 6 first.
Example 3
In a row of tables, 1 table has 4 seats and each new table adds 2 seats. How many seats are there with 50 tables?
| Tables | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Seats | 4 | 6 | 8 | 10 | 12 |
- Drawing 50 tables or making a table with 50 rows is very long.
- Look for the pattern: each new table adds 2 seats.
- From table 1 to table 50 there are 49 jumps of 2: 49 × 2 = 98.
- Seats: 4 + 98 = 102.
- Check with a few tables: with 5 tables, 4 + 4 × 2 = 12, as in the table.
With 50 tables there are 102 seats.
Watch out! Here many people count 50 jumps instead of 49 and say 104.
A challenge to think about
Choose a problem from your maths book or make one up. Solve it with two different strategies and note how many steps you needed with each one. Then decide which was more efficient and explain why: is it shorter, safer, or does it work with larger numbers? Change the numbers for much larger ones and see which of the two still works.
Practise
Rounds of 10 questions. Choose a level:
Your grade in this topic:No grade yetDo a round at the Basic level to get a grade.