Posing your own maths questions from everyday situations
Machine translation
Learn
A problem starts with a question, and you can ask that question yourself. Look at an everyday scene and find the numbers in it.
Ellie's scene: 12 loaves in the basket and 8 on the tray To ask a good question, follow three steps. First, look at the scene and count what is there. Then choose what you want to find out. Finally, write the question using “how many” or “how much”.
1. Look and count 2. Choose what you want to find out 3. Write the question
The three steps for asking a question One scene gives you lots of questions. Ellie has 12 loaves in the basket and 8 on the tray. You could ask how many there are in total, how many more there are in the basket, or how many are left if she sells 5. Each question needs a different calculation.
Question Calculation How many in total? 12 + 8 = 20 How many more in the basket? 12 − 8 = 4 Sells 5: how many are left? 20 − 5 = 15 Three questions from the same scene, each with its own calculation A good maths question can be answered using the information in the scene. Its answer is a number. And it asks something you really want to know. “What colour is the bread?” is not a maths question.
You can also start with a calculation. Look at 12 − 5. Think of a story that takes away: “Ellie has 12 loaves and sells 5. How many loaves are left?” Then answer your question in a sentence.
The calculation 12 − 5 with a story: take away 5 loaves
Worked examples
Example 1
Look at Mara's shop: 3 boxes with 6 pencils each and 4 loose pencils. Write three different maths questions and answer one of them.
- Look and count: there are 3 boxes with 6 pencils and 4 loose pencils.
- Question 1: how many pencils are in the boxes? That is 6 + 6 + 6 = 18.
- Question 2: how many pencils are there in total? That is 18 + 4 = 22.
- Question 3: how many more pencils are in the boxes than loose? That is 18 − 4 = 14.
- Check: all three can be answered using the information in the scene, and each answer is a number.
Three good questions. For example, in total there are 22 pencils.
Watch out! Here many people ask something the scene does not tell you, such as “how much does each pencil cost?”.
Example 2
Gus is looking at Mara's price list, with a magnifying glass for £5, a torch for £7 and a bell for £3. He asks: “How much does it cost?”. Can the question be improved?
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Magnifier | 5 € |
| Torch | 7 € |
| Bell | 3 € |
- Read Gus's question: “How much does it cost?”. It does not say which thing, so it cannot be answered.
- Choose what you want to find out: how much two things cost together.
- Write the question with all the information: “How much do a magnifying glass and a torch cost?”.
- Answer using the information in the table: 5 + 7 = 12.
The improved question is “How much do a magnifying glass and a torch cost?”, and the answer is £12.
Watch out! Here many people leave the question without saying which thing they mean.
Example 3
This is the calculation: 15 − 6. Make up a story with Julie and her stickers, and a question that is answered by that calculation.
- Think of a story that takes away: Julie gives stickers away.
- Write down the information: Julie has 15 stickers and gives 6 to Crumb.
- Write the question: how many stickers does she have left?
- Answer with the calculation: 15 − 6 = 9.
“Julie has 15 stickers and gives 6 to Crumb. How many stickers does she have left?”. She has 9 left.
Watch out! Here many people make up a story that adds, even though the calculation is a subtraction.
A challenge to think about
Choose a scene from your home or your classroom: the breakfast table, your backpack or the playground. Count what is there and write three different maths questions: one answered by adding, one by subtracting and one with equal groups. Ask someone to answer them and see whether they understand each question without you explaining anything. If a question is missing some information, improve it and try again.
This topic has no questions yet.
Next topic: Evaluating and comparing strategies; choosing the most efficient →